How to Modify Child Support on Long Island: New York Legal Guide

When Life Changes, So Should Your Child Support Order

Your life isn’t static, and neither is your child’s. Job loss, income changes, growing medical needs, or shifts in child custody can all dramatically affect your child’s financial needs and your ability to meet your obligations.

On Long Island New York, child support orders are difficult to modify, but are not “set in stone.” If your circumstances have changed, you have the legal right to request a modification of your existing child support order. This goes both ways; whether you’re paying or receiving child support payments.

On Long Island, which is governed by New York State laws, modifying Child Support orders is, by its nature, very difficult. It’s important to get it right the first time. New York State law has only a few, very strict options to modify these kinds of agreements once they are in place.

At Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C., our family law attorneys have decades of experience helping parents across Nassau and Suffolk counties seek, negotiate, and litigate child support modifications that reflect their evolving realities.

Understanding the Legal Basis for Child Support Modifications on Long Island, NY

On Long Island, a child support modification isn’t automatic. You must formally request a change through the Family Court in Nassau County or Family Court in Suffolk County. Simply agreeing to a new amount with your co-parent (without court approval) may not be enforceable and can even backfire legally.

Under New York State law, a parent may request a change to an existing child support order if:

#1. There’s Been a Substantial Change in Circumstances

This is the most flexible and most commonly used standard. It means that something material and ongoing has changed since the order was issued. Examples include:

• Involuntary job loss or long-term reduction in income
• A child develops medical or special needs
• A parent becomes permanently disabled
• Change in the cost of health insurance or childcare
• One parent relocates or remarries in a way that affects finances
• A parent has another child to support
• Significant increase in the custodial parent’s income
• A child becomes emancipated

This standard allows the court to assess the totality of the circumstances rather than rigid formulas.

#2. It’s Been Three Years Since the Last Order

If three years have passed since the current child support order was entered or last modified, either parent may request a review to see if the amount is still appropriate, even if no major life changes occurred.

This provision accounts for inflation, raises, cost-of-living changes, and shifts in family dynamics over time.

#3. A Parent’s Income Has Changed by 15% or More

New York state law permits a support modification if either parent’s income has increased or decreased by 15% or more since the last order.

This rule is objective – but it does not apply if:

• The change was intentional (e.g., quitting a high-paying job to avoid support)
• The income fluctuation is temporary or seasonal
• The existing order was issued before October 13, 2010 (unless the parties opted into the new standard)

Common Scenarios Where a Child Support Modification May Be Needed

✔ You Lost Your Job or Had Hours Cut

If your employment was terminated or your work hours were reduced through no fault of your own, you may qualify for a reduction in child support.

It’s important to act quickly and file a petition immediately. Failure to file promptly means arrears will continue to accrue based on the old amount and you may be liable for thousands of dollars in back support you can’t afford.

✔ Your Co-Parent Received a Significant Raise or Promotion

If you are the custodial parent and the other parent’s income has gone up substantially, you may be eligible for an increase in support. On Long Island, Nassau County and Suffolk County Family courts expect both parents to contribute proportionally to a child’s financial needs.

✔ Your Child Now Has Increased Medical or Educational Needs

If your child has been diagnosed with a health condition, is transitioning to private school, or now requires tutoring or special services, these are valid reasons to revisit your order.

✔ You Now Have Primary Custody or Your Parenting Time Has Shifted

If your child now lives with you more than 50 percent of the time, or if you’ve been awarded full custody, you may no longer be obligated to pay support, and may even become eligible to receive it instead.

The Legal Process to Modify Child Support on Long Island, NY

Modifications are handled through Family Court or the Supreme Court (if your support order was part of a divorce judgment) in the county in which you reside. Here’s what the process generally involves:

#1. Filing a Petition for Modification

You must submit a formal petition to the appropriate court (usually Family Court in your county). The petition must clearly explain:

What change in circumstances has occurred
When and why the change happened
What new support amount you are seeking
Supporting documentation (pay stubs, custody orders, medical bills, etc.)

Note: The change in support is not retroactive to the date your situation changed. It is effective only to the date you filed the petition, so don’t delay in filing. Delays can cost you.

#2. Serving the Other Parent

The other parent must be formally served with the petition. This ensures they have notice of the proceeding and an opportunity to respond.

#3. Court Hearing

At the hearing, both parties can present evidence, financial documents, and arguments. The judge will consider:

• The child’s current needs
• Each parent’s income and financial situation
• Changes in custody or parenting time
• Any relevant court orders (e.g., spousal support)

If both parties agree to a modification in advance, the judge can issue a consent order without a formal trial.

#4. Judge’s Decision

The appropriate county court will issue a new order reflecting any changes in the amount, frequency, and method of payment. The new order becomes legally binding and enforceable.

What If My Child Support Modification Petition Is Denied in Nassau County or Suffolk County Court?

If the judge finds that you failed to meet the burden of proof, or that your change was temporary, self-imposed, or insubstantial, your request may be denied.

A denied petition doesn’t bar you from filing again later, but it may weaken your credibility. That’s why experienced child support legal representation is critical in building a strong, fact-based case.

How Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. Can Help Your Child Support Modification

We understand how overwhelming it can be to seek or respond to a child support modification, especially while dealing with financial stress, job loss, or custody changes. Our legal team is here to help you:

✔ Evaluate whether you qualify for a modification
✔ File your petition correctly and efficiently
✔ Gather and present persuasive financial documentation
✔ Negotiate with your co-parent for a fair agreement
✔ Represent you at Family Court hearings
✔ Enforce or defend against support changes based on the law

We don’t take shortcuts – we build strong, thoughtful cases tailored to your unique situation and goals.

Take Control of Your Child Support Obligations Today

If your financial situation has changed or your child’s needs have evolved, don’t wait. The earlier you act, the more options you have – and the more likely you are to avoid unnecessary arrears, penalties, or legal issues.

Let Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. help you pursue a modification that reflects your current reality and protects your rights. Contact ustoday for a free consultation.

📞 Call us now for a free, confidential consultation: 631-923-1910
📍 Serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties on Long Island
🕒 Evening and virtual appointments available