Home »
Who’s Responsible for a Child’s College Costs After Divorce?
Planning for college after divorce can feel overwhelming, especially when tuition bills arrive right as families are adjusting to new households, new budgets, and new routines. If you’re co-parenting on Long Island, you should know that Nassau and Suffolk courts may treat higher-education costs as part of your child’s ongoing support needs in certain situations, and judges often expect parents to share those expenses in a way that reflects their financial circumstances.
This guide will walk you through the practical basics of how Nassau and Suffolk County courts commonly approach college contributions, including how the “SUNY cap” can limit (or shape) what a parent may be ordered to pay, what types of expenses may be included beyond tuition, and why the specific language in your divorce agreement matters. Whether you and your co-parent are on the same page or are already disagreeing about school choice, living arrangements, or who pays for what, getting clarity early can reduce conflict later and help you build a plan that supports your child’s education while protecting your financial stability.
Planning ahead matters. If your divorce or support agreement doesn’t clearly address college costs, New York courts may step in later and make those decisions for you. Speaking with a Long Island family law attorney early can help you understand what courts typically expect, and how to protect yourself before tuition bills arrive. A short consultation now can prevent expensive disputes later. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Key Takeaways from This Article
- On Long Island, parents are often shocked to find out that New York state law can require them to help pay for college until a child turns 21, even if the kid is technically an adult and even if the parents don’t see eye to eye on their child’s college plans at all.
- New York’s child support rules treat college as part of a child’s basic support in many cases, so tuition, room and board, and fees can all get rolled into child support obligations if the court thinks it’s reasonable.
- The famous “SUNY cap” isn’t a hard-and-fast rule, it’s more like a guideline courts use to limit a parent’s college contribution to the cost of a typical SUNY school. Judges can however go above that if the facts justify it.
- When parents clash over private vs public school, living on campus vs commuting, or even whether the child should go to college at all, Nassau and Suffolk courts look at the child’s ability, the family’s finances, and the pre-divorce lifestyle to break the tie.
- A well-drafted divorce agreement can spell out who pays what for everything from tuition, books, housing, and travel, and can tie contributions to actual grades, full-time status, and whether the child applies for loans or scholarships.
- Support orders aren’t carved in stone. If college costs explode or someone loses a job or starts making a lot more money, you can go back to court and ask to modify support or college contribution terms.
- If you’re worried about how your kid’s college is going to get paid after divorce on Long Island, getting legal advice early can save you a ton of stress and make sure your agreement actually protects your child’s education.
Navigating Child Support and College Tuition on Long Island
On Long Island, child support doesn’t just vanish when your offspring hits 18, it often runs until 21, which is exactly the window when tuition bills explode. You’re dealing with the NY Child Support Standards Act (CSSA) on one side and SUNY cap arguments on the other, so your agreement has to spell out who pays what, when, and how. If you skip that level of detail, you end up back in court later, fighting over refunds, 529 withdrawals, or whether a private school is “reasonable.”
The Child Support Equation in New York
Instead of just plugging your income into a calculator, you’re really juggling two big buckets: basic support and add-ons like college. New York courts can treat tuition as an “add-on” under the CSSA, especially if your income is above the cap or your child goes beyond the SUNY level. That means your percentages for child support (say 65/35) often carry over to tuition too, unless your agreement clearly carves out a different formula at the start.
College costs often blur the line between child support and add-on expenses. If your agreement doesn’t clearly define how tuition fits into support—or whether it’s included or separate—you could be exposed to overlapping obligations. An attorney can help ensure your support structure reflects New York law and your real-world finances. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
What About Extra Expenses?
Beyond the raw tuition number, you’ve got a pile of extras: dormitory fees, meal plans, lab fees, books, even a laptop that may cost more than your first car. On Long Island, it’s common for parenting agreements to split those add-ons by income percentage, right down to campus health insurance and travel back home for breaks. If you don’t lock this down in writing now, you’ll probably argue later about whether that $1,200 “technology fee” is really part of college costs for purposes of child support.
Instead of treating these extras like an afterthought, you want to list them like a checklist: room and board:
- Dorm rent
- Meal plan
- Books
- Lab Fees
- Transportation
- Study abroad
- Application fees
- SAT prep
- Grad school (if that’s on the table)
Courts in Nassau and Suffolk will often enforce detailed language like “each parent pays 50% of tuition, mandatory fees, room and board, books, and required technology,” and that one sentence can save you thousands in legal fees later. You can even agree to cap each parent’s share at a SUNY level but still split extras above that, which gives you flexibility if your child gets into a pricey private school you actually want to say yes to.
Details matter more than most parents expect. Vague language about “college costs” often leads to disputes over technology fees, housing, travel, and even health insurance. Clearly defining these expenses upfront, before emotions run high, can save thousands in legal fees and years of frustration. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Our Take on What’s Needed for College Support
Over the past few years, I’ve seen Long Island judges take college costs way more seriously, especially once kids start getting those $60,000-a-year private school acceptances. You really need clear language on the SUNY cap, who pays for housing, books, travel, and what happens if your child chooses a school twice the SUNY cost. Any solid plan should also spell out how 529 accounts are used and whether support continues past age 21 if your child is still in school.
A strong college plan is both legal and practical. It should reflect current SUNY benchmarks, realistic housing costs, financial aid expectations, and how 529 funds are used. If your agreement was drafted years ago, or never mentioned college at all, it may not hold up when real tuition numbers hit. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Key Child Support and College Factors to Consider
In New York, you’re usually talking support up to age 21, but college provisions can stretch obligations if you agree to it in writing. Judges will quietly look at income, assets, your child’s academic record, and whether a SUNY option is realistic compared to a $70,000 private program. Any agreement that breaks down tuition, room and board, fees, travel, and health insurance by percentage is way easier to enforce later.
- Each parent’s income and bonuses or commissions
- 529 balances and who controls withdrawals
- Your child’s grades, major, and realistic career path
- Exact SUNY benchmark you’re using for the cap
Tips for Talking to Your Ex About College Tuition
Conversations with your ex can get heated when the big numbers of college are discussed. Instead of lobbing angry emails back and forth with your ex, you’ll get further if you show hard numbers: SUNY tuition vs. private, expected aid, and what your child is actually being offered. Try framing it as “how do we both help our kid without sinking our own futures” rather than relitigating your divorce. Assume that written follow-up by text or email confirming every tuition-related conversation will save you when memories get fuzzy two years from now.
- Share financial aid letters and net price calculators
- Suggest a short Zoom call with the college’s financial aid office
- Keep the focus on your child’s needs, not past grievances
- Put every agreement in writing right after you talk
When you sit down for that tuition talk, it helps to show up with a simple spreadsheet: projected costs for 4 years, your proposal for splitting them, and what happens if loans are needed. You can even anchor the conversation around the SUNY cap so you’re both working from a shared number, then decide together if you’ll go above it and by how much. Assume that the more specific you are about deadlines, payment methods, and how to handle missed payments, the fewer panicked texts you’ll trade right before a tuition bill is due.
- Bring printouts of SUNY costs vs. each private offer
- List deadlines for deposits, housing, and payment plans
- Talk about who pays what if your child studies abroad or needs an extra semester
- Assume that you’ll need to revise the plan if income or financial aid changes significantly
The Pros and Cons of Paying College Costs on Long Island
Over the last few years, more Long Island judges have been signing off on very detailed college cost clauses, and that cuts both ways for you. Locking in who pays what can protect your child’s education, but it can also box you into big bills if tuition jumps 4% a year or if your income drops. You really want to see how those SUNY cap numbers, room and board, and extras like study abroad actually play out over four full years.
| Pros | Cons |
| Gives your child stability and a clear path to a 4-year degree | Locks you into payments even if your income falls later on |
| Reduces conflict because expectations are set in writing | May require you to pay more than the SUNY cap if you agree to it |
| Can be tailored so both parents share costs by percentage of income | Harder to modify without going back to court and showing a big change |
| Lets you cap extras like housing, meal plans, and travel ahead of time | Doesn’t always account for unexpected expenses like a fifth year |
| May reduce future legal fights about textbooks, fees, and laptops | Can overlap awkwardly with child support if the deal isn’t drafted carefully |
| Gives you leverage to insist on grade requirements or full-time status | Can create resentment if one parent feels “stuck” paying more |
| Encourages your child to apply for scholarships and financial aid | FAFSA rules may still count you as a contributor even if you can’t pay |
| Lets you plan long-term with 529 plans or other savings | May limit your ability to save for retirement or younger kids |
| Can align with NY law on educational expenses to keep things predictable | If the agreement is vague, you might get pulled into repeated disputes |
| Shows your child both parents are invested despite the divorce | Big tuition at private schools can blow past what you realistically afford |
When conversations stall, structure helps. Mediation or attorney-guided negotiations can turn emotional disagreements into concrete, enforceable plans based on numbers, not assumptions. Getting help doesn’t mean escalating conflict; it often prevents it. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Why It Might Make Sense to Include College Costs in Divorce Agreement
With college costs on Long Island creeping into the $30,000 to $70,000 a year range, hammering out who pays what can actually save you headaches later. You might decide to split tuition above the SUNY cap 60/40, tie payments to financial aid awards, or agree that you’ll both cover books and fees equally. It can feel like a lot now, but it often avoids ugly, expensive court fights when your child is already packing for freshman year.
Things to Consider Before Committing to a College Clause in Your Divorce Agreement
Before you sign off on any college clause, you want to think past freshman year and into all four years. How stable is your job, your health, your remarriage plans, your other children’s timelines? What if your child chooses a private school instead of SUNY or wants to dorm in Manhattan at double the cost? The more you build in flexibility and clear limits now, the less you’ll be scrambling to modify child support orders later.
In practical terms, that means you look at hard numbers, not just good intentions. You factor in your net income, typical SUNY tuition, room and board, and what happens if your child takes a leave of absence or needs a fifth year. You also spell out conditions: full-time enrollment, GPA minimums, required FAFSA applications, and how 529 funds or grandparent contributions get counted. And because NY courts treat college as part of support, you want language that explains whether payments are in addition to, or instead of, basic child support so you don’t accidentally agree to double dip obligations without realizing it.
Step-by-Step: How to Work College Costs Out
Starting the Conversation
Instead of jumping straight into tuition numbers, you start with expectations: is your child looking at SUNY, private, or community college, and how does that line up with the SUNY cap you’ve read about. You talk through who will handle FAFSA, who claims the child for tax credits, and what happens if your child takes 5 years instead of 4, so nobody’s blindsided senior year.
Making a Plan That Works for Everyone
While child support and the SUNY cap give you a legal framework, your actual plan lives in the details: who pays what percent of tuition, housing, meal plans, and travel, and how that shifts if income changes by, say, 15% or more. You build in deadlines for sharing financial aid letters, annual review dates, and what happens if your child chooses a school way above SUNY rates.
Stick to Specifics
Some conversations go off the rails fast, but this one lands better when you anchor it to concrete stuff like the SUNY cap and your actual incomes right now, not old numbers from the divorce. You can say, “If our kid picks a CUNY or SUNY, are we both good paying our percentages from the agreement, and what if they push for a $70,000 private school?” That kind of specific question keeps it from turning into a fight about past grievances.
Making a Plan That Works for Everyone
Different from arguing over fairness in the abstract, you map out real-life scenarios: 4-year SUNY cost, 4-year private cost, maybe even a 2+2 community to SUNY route, then see where each of you can realistically plug in. You tie your shares to actual income percentages or the New York child support formula, not guesses, and you write in how you’ll revisit things if someone loses a job or gets a big promotion. That way your child isn’t stuck in the middle when money shifts.
In practice, you might spell it out like this: you cover 60% of SUNY-level tuition and fees, your ex covers 40%, your child kicks in summer earnings up to, say, $5,000 a year, and anything above SUNY costs is a separate discussion before deposits are paid. You fold in housing rules too. Maybe you split on-campus room and board, but cap off-campus rent at a specific dollar amount tied to Long Island or campus-area averages. And because life happens, you add a clause that if either of you has a 20% income swing, you’ll sit down (or mediate) within 30 days to tweak the college share instead of racing back to court every time.
Honest Conversations: When You Don’t See Eye to Eye
Nothing shocks parents more than realizing you both love your child but have totally different ideas about paying for college. One of you might swear by the SUNY cap while the other is dead set on a private school with a $70,000 sticker price. When that happens, you’re not just arguing over money; you’re arguing over expectations, values, and how far your legal obligations under New York child support law really go.
Finding Common Ground
One surprisingly effective move is to separate emotions from actual numbers and pull out concrete data. You look at SUNY tuition, room and board totals, then compare them to your child’s dream school costs, and suddenly the argument shifts. Instead of fighting in circles, you’re talking about splitting percentages, capping each parent’s annual contribution, and tying payments to your actual incomes. That’s where a detailed written college clause in your agreement can really save you.
What to Do If You Can’t Agree
When you hit a wall, you don’t just throw up your hands and hope the judge sorts it out. You pivot to options like mediation, a written cost-sharing formula, or, if you really need to, a formal court application to modify support so it actually reflects college expenses. Nassau and Suffolk county Judges on Long Island see these fights all the time, and they usually look at your past involvement, your incomes, and whether the school choice is reasonable under the SUNY cap idea.
In real life, this might look like one parent pushing for a $65,000 per year private school while the other says, “I’ll pay my share of SUNY, nothing more.” When that stalemate hits, you bring in a mediator or your attorney and start talking specifics: can you each pay up to the SUNY rate, with your child taking loans or scholarships to fill the gap, or do you need the court to set a hard formula based on your incomes, say 60/40 or 70/30. And if your original divorce agreement never mentioned college, you may be filing a petition to modify support so it spells out who pays what going forward, instead of just winging it every semester.
For more information, read How To Enforce Court Orders & Protect Property After Divorce on Long Island, NY
If college is on the horizon—or already here—this is the moment to act. Whether you need to clarify an existing order, negotiate contributions, or seek a modification, timing matters. Waiting until bills are due often limits your options. Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Navigating Who Pays College Costs in Divorced Family on Long Island? We Can Help
Who pays the costs for your child’s higher education can become a heated and difficult issue, especially if it is not addressed in your initial divorce agreement. While it’s best to handle these issues upfront, if your child is approaching college age and your child support agreement does not address these costs, you need an experienced family law attorney to help sort them out.
With the right legal strategy, professional guidance, and long-term planning, families across Long Island successfully build support plans that truly work.
If you are navigating the issue of paying for college for your child, you may not be able to do it alone.
Call Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. today at 631-923-1910 to protect your child’s education and your financial future.
For more information, read How To Enforce Court Orders & Protect Property After Divorce on Long Island, NY
Why Work With Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C.
Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. has extensive experience handling complex divorce and child support cases throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties.
We have extensive experience working with:
- College tuition
- College related expenses to
- The “Suny” cap
- 529 accounts
- Extended child support planning
- Local court expectations and judges
Your child’s future deserves more than a cookie-cutter agreement.
Schedule a Free Confidential Consultation and Case Evaluation
The right plan protects both your child’s education and your financial future. With clear expectations, enforceable terms, and realistic limits, families across Long Island successfully navigate college costs without constant conflict. Getting guidance now can make the next four years far more manageable.
Call 631-923-1910 to request a free confidential consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney.
Ensure your child’s education is secure – schedule a free consultation today.
GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION TODAY
Call 631-923-1910 or fill in the form below
At your consultation, we will:
- Conduct a Comprehensive Review of your particular situation
- Provide a Full Explanation of the Legal Issues involved in your matter
- Discuss your Goals and Objectives
- Develop a Strategic Plan to Achieve your Goals
- Answer All of Your Questions & Concerns
- Provide Advice on collecting Key Documentation and Evidence to gather to achieve your desired outcome
Your attorney will describe the many options available to determine together the right solution for you. By the end of this conversation, we’ll all understand how we can best help you to move forward.
No Cost or Obligation
There is no cost or obligation for this initial consultation. It is simply an opportunity for us to get to know each other, answer your questions and learn if Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. is right the right law firm for you. Give us a call at 631-923-1910 or fill in the short form below for your free consultation and case evaluation.
By submitting this webform, you consent to receiving periodic text messages from us. Message and data rates may apply. We assure you that your information will not be sold or provided to third parties. To opt out, reply 'Stop.' For assistance, reply 'Help.'
About the Author
Robert E. Hornberger, Esq., Founding Partner, Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C.
- Over 20 years practicing matrimonial law
- Over 1,000 cases successfully resolved
- Founder and Partner of Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C.
- Experienced and compassionate Long Island Divorce Attorney, Family Law Attorney, and Divorce Mediator
- Licensed to practice law in the State of New York
- New York State Bar Association member
- Nassau County Bar Association member
- Suffolk County Bar Association member
- “Super Lawyer” Metro Rising Star
- Nominated Best of Long Island Divorce Attorney four consecutive years
- Alternative Dispute Resolution Committee Contributor
- Collaborative Law Association of New York – Former Director
- Martindale Hubbell Distinguished Designation
- America’s Most Honored Professionals – Top 5%
- Lead Counsel Rated – Divorce Law
- American Institute of Family Law Attorneys 10 Best
- International Academy of Collaborative Professionals
- Graduate of Hofstra University School of Law
- Double Bachelor’s degrees in Philosophy, Politics & Law and History from SUNY Binghamton University
- Full Robert E. Hornberger, Esq. Bio
Frequently Asked Questions About Who Pays College Expenses After Divorce
Who usually pays for college after a divorce on Long Island?
This matters a lot because college is insanely expensive and you don’t want your child stuck in the middle while you and your ex argue over who writes the checks. In New York, there is no automatic rule that says “mom pays” or “dad pays” or even “both pay 50-50” for college.
Instead, a judge can order one or both parents to contribute to college costs as part of child support or a separate “college expense” provision. A lot of the time, this gets negotiated in the divorce settlement so that both parents know ahead of time what their share looks like and what kind of schools and costs you’re actually talking about.
How do New York child support laws deal with college costs?
New York child support law technically covers basic support like food, housing, clothing, that kind of thing, up to age 21 in most cases. College tuition, room and board, and books are treated as “add-on” expenses that a judge can make parents contribute to if it’s appropriate based on their income and circumstances.
On Long Island, courts look at the parents’ earnings, the child’s academic ability, the type of college, and the family’s lifestyle during the marriage. So if college was always expected, talked about (maybe you were touring campuses), the court is much more likely to say parents should chip in, and then figure out what amounts are reasonably fair.
What is the SUNY cap and how does it affect what I pay?
The “SUNY cap” is a big deal in New York divorces, especially on Long Island where private colleges are all over the place. It’s basically a guideline that pegs each parent’s college contribution to the cost of a State University of New York (SUNY) school, even if your child goes to a more expensive private college.
So if your child chooses a private school that costs way more than a SUNY school, many agreements say the parents only have to pay up to what a typical SUNY tuition, room and board would be. Anything above that is either the student’s responsibility or something you and your ex can choose to cover voluntarily if you’re able and willing to help more.
What happens if parents totally disagree about paying for college?
Disagreements over paying for collage are very common. One parent might think community college is fine, while the other wants a pricey private school. Or, someone feels they just can’t afford what the other is pushing. When that happens, Nassau and Suffolk courts can step in and decide whether college contributions are appropriate and if so, how much you each have to pay.
The judge will look at your original divorce agreement, your current finances, the child’s needs and abilities, and how realistic the school choice is for your situation. If there was never any clear college language in your divorce or child support agreement, you might end up in court asking for a ruling, so getting advice before that point is usually a smart move.
Can we negotiate college expenses in our divorce settlement instead of leaving it to a judge?
Absolutely, and most parents are better off doing exactly that. You can spell out things like how you’ll split tuition, whether you use a SUNY cap, what happens with room and board, books, fees, health insurance at school, even travel home on holidays if you want to be that detailed.
Parents also often set conditions, like the child must stay enrolled full time, maintain a certain GPA, and apply for financial aid, scholarships, maybe work part time. The more specific your agreement is, the fewer fights you’ll have later on when the bills start hitting your inbox and everyone conveniently “remembers” the conversations differently.
If my financial situation changes, can college payment terms be modified?
Life happens: people lose jobs, get sick, remarry, have more kids, and suddenly the college plan that seemed fine 5 years ago is a lot harder to pull off now. On Long Island, you can ask a Nassau or Suffolk court to modify support or college contribution terms if there’s been a substantial change in circumstances.
This might mean lowering what you pay, changing the percentage split, or even adjusting expectations about what kind of school is realistic. The key is not waiting until you’re drowning in bills and collection notices, because courts are a lot more receptive when you come in earlier and show good faith.
How can I protect my child's education when I'm going through or after a divorce?
If you’re on Long Island and you’re worried about how college is going to get funded, you’re definitely not overthinking it; you’re doing what a good parent does. You protect your child’s education by getting clear, written terms in your divorce agreement or support order, instead of relying on vague promises like “we’ll figure it out when the time comes”.
It helps a lot to sit down with someone who actually knows how Long Island courts treat college costs and SUNY caps and all the rest, so you don’t miss something that comes back to haunt you later.
“Going through a divorce is never easy, but Hornberger Verbitsky made the process smooth, respectful, and solution-focused. I worked closely with attorney Anne Marie Lanni, who was outstanding in every way. She resolved conflicts with professionalism, communicated clearly and effectively, and authored an agreement that was thoughtful and fair. Her attention to detail and calm, competent approach gave me real peace of mind.
Lead attorney Rob was also fantastic—personable, friendly, and genuinely supportive throughout. He made a tough process feel manageable and always took time to check in and make sure I felt heard and supported.
The team’s commitment to a problem-solving approach, their impressive professional network, and even their supportive nature and community values really set them apart. I felt like more than just a case—I felt cared for and well-represented.
Highly recommend Hornberger Verbitsky if you want trusted guidance and a team that gets results with integrity and compassion.”
