Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
Learn how to protect yourself against false child abuse & neglect accusations with lawyers specializing in child abuse defense Free Consult631-923-1910
Home »
Section Links:
(click a link below to go right to that section):
- How Family Disputes Can Result in Criminal Child Abuse Charges in NY
- Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
- Understanding Child Abuse & Neglect Under New York State Law
- Defining Abuse: Key Legal Distinctions in New York State
- Categories of Child Abuse and Neglect
- Types of Child Neglect Accusations
- Family Court vs. Criminal Court: A Critical Comparison
- What to Do If CPS Investigates You on Long Island
- Our Three-Step Defense Strategy
- What Happens During CPS Investigations?
- The CPS Investigation Process Explained
- Essential Tips for Handling CPS Investigations
- Understand Your Rights During CPS Investigations
- Protecting Parental Rights in Divorce & Custody
- Safeguarding Your Parental Rights Amidst Accusations
- The Impact of Allegations on Custody Arrangements
- Strategies for Effective Defense in Custody Matters
- Clearing the Fog: Common Questions Answered
- Triggers for CPS Investigations
- Rights and Responsibilities during Interrogations
- Accused of Child Abuse or Neglect? Get Help Now
- Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
- Frequently Asked Questions About Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
Key Takeaways on Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
- Child abuse and neglect in New York include physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, as well as failure to provide basic needs like food, shelter, supervision, and education.
- Family Court investigations (CPS/ACS) and criminal proceedings operate separately but can both impact parental rights and freedom.
- Building a strong defense involves gathering clear evidence, exposing any hidden motives behind accusations, and understanding your legal rights during investigations.
- Early consultation with an experienced attorney during CPS or ACS investigations helps navigate the process and safeguards your interests.
- Allegations of abuse or neglect significantly influence custody and visitation arrangements, so strategic legal representation is vital.
- Cooperating with authorities while preserving evidence and maintaining proper legal guidance can improve case outcomes.
- Free consultations with specialized Long Island family law attorneys are available to assist parents facing allegations and protect family relationships.
Many divorce and family law cases on Long Island, NY involve allegations of child abuse or neglect. Because actual child abuse or neglect are such horrifying events, people can be quick to assume that the allegations are accurate and the person accused is guilty. However, all too often, these allegations are baselessly levied by a spiteful spouse trying to hurt their ex and their relationship with their children because they are angry about the divorce process.
Domestic violence and child abuse are serious charges and if you are wrongfully accused, your relationship with your children and your future are on the line. You need to act quickly to protect yourself, your children and your reputation from a guilty verdict.
Here’s how you can safeguard your rights under New York law and when you should think about getting an experienced Long Island divorce and family law attorney involved to protect you.
How Family Disputes Can Result in Criminal Child Abuse Charges on Long Island, NY
Family legal cases are wrought with emotion, especially when children are involved. It’s not uncommon for one parent to attempt to gain control over a divorce or child custody battle by falsely accusing the other parent of some kind of domestic abuse.
Because abuse tends to happen behind closed doors with few witnesses, little evidence beyond the initial testimony is needed to pursue criminal charges. Naturally, courts on Long Island, NY act swiftly in reports of child neglect or abuse to protect children from harm. However, even when the allegations of abuse or neglect aren’t legitimate, custody and visitation rights may be revoked from the accused parent without real cause.
Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
Most people confronted with child abuse or neglect allegations feel overwhelmed by the serious consequences they face. If you are dealing with such accusations on Long Island, NY, you need to understand how the legal system works and what steps to take to protect your rights and your family. As a divorce and family law attorney with over 20 years of experience practicing on Long Island, I am here to guide you through the complexities of Family Court in Nassau County and Suffolk County as well as criminal proceedings in Criminal Court in Suffolk County and Nassau County. I hope to help you build a strong defense against false or exaggerated claims. Your future and your relationship with your children depend on a clear, informed approach.
Understanding Child Abuse & Neglect Under New York State Law
In New York State, child abuse and neglect are serious legal matters governed by the Family Court Act and Social Services Law. Abuse typically refers to the infliction of physical, emotional, or sexual harm by a parent or caregiver, while neglect involves the failure to provide adequate food, shelter, supervision, education, or medical care. The New York State Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS) investigates allegations of abuse or neglect, often through local Child Protective Services (CPS). These cases can lead to court involvement, removal of children from the home, or even criminal charges, making it crucial for accused parents to understand their rights and obtain legal representation immediately.
Defining Abuse: Key Legal Distinctions in New York State
Under New York law, child abuse and neglect are legally distinct and carry different definitions and consequences. Abuse typically involves an act of commission—such as striking a child or engaging in inappropriate sexual behavior—while neglect usually involves an act of omission, like failing to provide necessary care or supervision. Emotional abuse, though harder to prove, may include repeated verbal threats, humiliation, or exposure to domestic violence. Understanding these distinctions is essential in defending against allegations, as each type of claim requires different forms of evidence and legal defense strategies.
Categories of Child Abuse and Neglect
Child abuse and neglect under New York state law encompass a broad range of behaviors, each with distinct legal implications. These definitions shape how cases proceed in Family Court or Criminal Court in Nassau and Suffolk counties on Long Island and underscore the importance of understanding the specific nature of the allegations against you. Each type demands different evidence and defense tactics in both family and criminal proceedings.
• Physical child abuse involves intentional harm or injury.
o Physical abuse includes injuries like bruises or fractures.
• Emotional child abuse can include verbal attacks or neglecting a child’s psychological needs.
o Emotional abuse covers verbal insults or consistent rejection
• Sexual child abuse is any exploitative act.
o Sexual abuse involves any non-consensual sexual contact
• Neglect refers to failing to provide imperatives like food, shelter, supervision, or education.
o Neglect generally means failing to supply basic necessities such as food, safe housing, adequate supervision, or schooling.
Types of Child Neglect Accusations
With this definition, there are many subcategories of child neglect allegations, some of which are discussed below:
Physical Neglect
Physical neglect refers to the failure to provide a child’s basic living necessities, including food, clothing, and shelter. A parent who has been falsely accused of physical neglect may be facing claims that there’s not enough food to eat at home or clean clothes that fit properly.
Many families who live in poverty are unable to meet the physical needs of their children, despite tremendous effort and willingness. A hateful ex can easily use this to gain control over your custody arrangements and make you look like a bad parent.
Emotional Neglect
Emotional neglect is the failure of a parent or caregiver to supply the child with the love and support necessary for healthy development. You may be falsely accused of failure to provide warmth, attention, supervision, affection, praise, or encouragement to a child.
Educational Neglect
Educational neglect includes failure to enroll school-aged children in school, allowing unexplained absences from school, refusal of recommended remedial services without good reason, and failure to respond to attendance questions.
In New York, a child may not miss 10% or more of school days. In a 180-day school year, this is 18 days, or approximately two days a month. Even when an absence from school is excused, such as for a doctor’s appointment, it’s counted toward this total.
Vengeful exes can levy allegations of educational neglect against primary custodians, prompting an unwarranted investigation into the parent. Truancy is punished harshly on Long Island, NY and accused parents may face legal penalties or even jail time.
Family Court vs. Criminal Court: A Critical Comparison
The Family Court focuses on the child’s safety and welfare, aiming to protect or reunify families, while Criminal Court prosecutes violations that could lead to incarceration. Family Court handles investigations, custody decisions, and protective orders, using a “preponderance of evidence” standard. Criminal Court cases require proof “beyond a reasonable doubt,” potentially resulting in harsher penalties but also stronger procedural safeguards for defendants.
Family Court vs. Criminal Court: Key Differences
Family Court (CPS/ACS) Criminal Court
Focuses on child protection and family welfare Focuses on punishing criminal conduct
Standard of proof: preponderance of the evidence (51% likelihood) Standard of proof: beyond a reasonable doubt
May order services, supervision, or temporary removal of the child Can result in fines, jail time, or probation
No right to a jury trial; judge makes decisions Defendants have a right to a jury trial
| Family Court (CPS/ACS) | Criminal Court |
| Focuses on child protection and family welfare | Focuses on punishing criminal conduct |
| Standard of proof: preponderance of the evidence (51% likelihood) | Standard of proof: beyond a reasonable doubt |
| May order services, supervision, or temporary removal of the child | Can result in fines, jail time, or probation |
| No right to a jury trial; judge makes decisions | Defendants have a right to a jury trial
|
Decisions in Family Court in Nassau County and Suffolk County directly affect your custody and visitation, often moving at a faster pace and emphasizing the child’s best interests. Criminal Court proceedings on Long Island, by contrast, prioritize determining guilt or innocence and carry potentially severe penalties, including imprisonment. Navigating both Family Court and Criminal Court simultaneously requires a strategic defense that addresses their different standards, procedures, and outcomes to protect your parental rights and personal freedom.
What to Do If CPS Investigates You on Long Island
At Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C., we have developed a three-step process to defend against Child Abuse & Neglect accusations.
Our Three-Step Defense Strategy
Building Your Defense: A Tactical Approach
Effective defense against Child Abuse & Neglect charges on Long Island, NY hinges on a focused, deliberate strategy. First, we need to collect unmistakable evidence. Next, we need to map out your timeline. Finally, we need to pinpoint inconsistencies in the accusations against you. From documented communications to credible witness accounts, every detail sharpens your case.
Identifying any underlying motives behind the allegations against you can often expose flaws in their case. During your case, you need to understand and protect your legal rights to ensure you don’t inadvertently weaken your position.
This tactical approach maximizes your chances to protect both your reputation and your parental rights.
1. Gathering Evidence and Establishing Alibis
Every piece of documented proof can make a pivotal difference in your case. Receipts, text messages, social media interactions, and witness statements all help to establish your whereabouts and conduct during the alleged incidents. For example, proving you were at work or with relatives during the reported time of the incident can dismantle false claims quickly. Organizing these materials systematically not only strengthens your defense but also signals to investigators and the court that you’re prepared and transparent.
2. Uncovering Motives Behind False Allegations
False accusations often arise from disputes unrelated to child welfare, such as child custody battles or retaliation after a separation. At Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C., we look closely at the context surrounding the claim. We review all communications that suggest potential threats, manipulation, or efforts to gain leverage in family court. In many Long Island cases, allegations surface just when custody or visitation rights are in flux, underscoring the importance of exposing these strategic, yet unfounded, motives.
Delving deeper into the accuser’s hidden motives often reveals patterns: a history of contentious interactions, attempts to delay proceedings, or financial disputes frequently accompany baseless allegations. As one example, we often see a parent file reports following a contentious custody modification or during a heated divorce negotiation. Recognizing these dynamics allows us to challenge the credibility of the accuser and present a fuller picture that courts and agencies would otherwise miss. Strategically framing these motives can shift focus back to the child’s best interests, rather than on the misleading claims of your accuser.
3. Navigating the Investigation Landscape
Investigations by Child Protective Services (CPS) on Long Island often begin quickly and can last weeks to months, involving interviews with you, your child, and others connected to your family. You’ll face detailed scrutiny over your living environment, caregiving practices, and any previous reports that may have been filed against you. It’s very important to your case to have timely legal counsel that can clarify how to best respond to the accusations to protect your interests. The interplay between Family Court and possible parallel criminal inquiries adds complexity, so understanding each step helps you anticipate what’s ahead and avoid missteps that could jeopardize your case.
What Happens During CPS Investigations?
CPS typically responds to reports within 24-48 hours, starting with an emergency safety assessment before a full investigation gets underway.
The CPS Investigation Process Explained
Investigators conduct home visits, collect statements, and review medical or school records. In Nassau and Suffolk counties, the process often includes Family Court hearings where interim orders may restrict custody or visitation rights. The entire investigation can take up to 60 days, but delays are common that could extend the time. We advise our clients to cooperate without over-sharing information. Always assume your responses will be documented and will be used in court to influence decisions about your parental fitness.
Essential Tips for Handling CPS Investigations
Approach the investigation methodically by:
• Documenting all interactions with CPS representatives, including dates and times.
• Avoiding spontaneous admissions or explanations without legal advice.
• Preserving relevant evidence, such as text messages or emails.
• Consulting an experienced family law attorney as soon as possible.
Recognizing your rights during questioning can prevent self-incrimination and help you maintain control over the narrative.
Understand Your Rights During CPS Investigations
Handling a CPS investigation demands a balance between cooperation and protecting your legal position. Take thorough notes during every contact with investigators to create a clear record and limit misunderstandings. If questioned directly, answer only what’s asked without elaborating to reduce exposure to misinterpretation. Retain an attorney familiar with Long Island’s family courts to ensure your responses align with your broader defense strategy. Physical evidence like medical reports or childcare receipts should be organized and readily available. Taking these steps early helps contain the investigation’s impact and supports your efforts to maintain your parental rights.
• Keep detailed logs of CPS visits and conversations, including any inconsistencies.
• Request copies of all reports and case notes from CPS when possible.
• Do not engage in social media discussions about the case.
• Limit direct contact with the opposing party to avoid escalating conflicts.
Recognizing these practical actions empowers you during tense and uncertain times.
Protecting Parental Rights in Divorce & Custody
Maintaining your parental rights during allegations requires decisive action and a strategic defense.
Safeguarding Your Parental Rights Amidst Accusations
Courts and agencies on Long Island take claims of child abuse and neglect very seriously. They will frequently adjust custody or visitation orders based on any perceived risk. By actively collaborating with your attorney, documenting your involvement in your child’s life, and demonstrating a commitment to their well-being, you can counterbalance negative assumptions influenced by the party making the accusations. Early legal intervention helps ensure that temporary decisions don’t become permanent obstacles to your relationship with your children.
The Impact of Allegations on Custody Arrangements
Allegations of abuse or neglect in Nassau County or Suffolk County can prompt the appropriate Family Court to impose emergency custody changes, often favoring the non-accused parent or temporary guardians. Such orders could restrict your visitation or mandate supervised visitation, even before formal findings. Courts prioritize child safety and will likely err on the side of caution. This places you at a disadvantage and will seem very unfair when you’ve done nothing wrong. You may feel as if you’ve been found guilty before the case is even investigated. Try to remember that their ultimate goal is to protect the child until all the facts come out. However, it’s important to understanding how these interim rulings can affect your long-term custody potential. It’s critical that you prepare a realistic defense and present your case effectively to regain or maintain your parental role.
Strategies for Effective Defense in Custody Matters
Presenting a strong defense involves compiling thorough evidence that disproves allegations. This evidence could consist of expert reports from therapists, character witnesses, and documented parenting activities. Crafting a comprehensive parenting plan that addresses safety concerns and proposes reunification therapies can demonstrate your willingness to cooperate with the court’s goals. Actively challenging questionable evidence and emphasizing your stable involvement often shifts perspectives in court, paving the way for you to gain greater access and custody rights to your child.
At Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. we focus on obtaining detailed witness statements and professional evaluations that speak to your parenting capabilities and the child’s welfare. For example, court-appointed evaluators’ reports from Suffolk Family Court can carry significant weight, so coordinating with these assessments is vital. Reunification therapy, when recommended, not only helps repair the parent-child relationship but also signals to the court your good faith effort. Balancing assertive legal representation with collaborative remedies often yields the best outcomes in custody disputes stemming from abuse or neglect claims.
Clearing the Fog: Common Questions Answered
Understanding the triggers for CPS investigations and your rights during questioning can make a significant difference in how you respond to the accusations. Many parents face situations where confusion and fear naturally cloud their judgment. It’s important to focus on the facts and legal protections that will help you build a stronger position. Below, I break down what typically sparks investigations and how best to handle interrogations without jeopardizing your case.
Triggers for CPS Investigations
Reports of child abuse or neglect often arise from mandated reporters like teachers or doctors, but neighbors, family members, and even anonymous tips can prompt investigations. Visible injuries, signs of malnutrition, or consistent absenteeism from school frequently trigger CPS involvement. In Nassau and Suffolk counties, CPS will move quickly to assess any credible concerns, especially if the child’s immediate safety is at risk. Being proactive and documenting your actions around your child’s care is critical to help clarify misunderstandings early on.
Rights and Responsibilities during Interrogations
Police or CPS interviews can feel intimidating, but never waive your right to have an attorney present. You have the right to remain silent during questioning and to request legal counsel before answering anything. Exercising your right to pause the conversation until counsel arrives protects against self-incrimination and preserves your defense. It’s especially important to challenge vague or leading questions to reduce the risk of false admissions or misinterpretations. This is often best handled by your attorney to reduce the appearance of defensiveness.
During interrogations, staying calm and methodical is key. You are not obligated to volunteer information beyond confirming basic identity details. If questioned by CPS or law enforcement, politely state that you wish to consult with your attorney before answering any questions. Avoid contradictory answers and refrain from speculating about accusations or motives. Taking detailed notes about the setting and questions asked afterward can be invaluable for your legal team. This approach helps maintain your position without inadvertently strengthening the opposition’s case against you.
Accused of Child Abuse or Neglect? Get Help Now
If you were accused of child neglect or abuse of any kind on Long Island, NY — be it physical, sexual, verbal, or emotional — it’s imperative that you secure legal representation as soon as possible. Child abuse and neglect charges can destroy your family, career, and your future.
When the charges are levied against you, the state begins building a case against you right away. Even if the accuser ends up recanting their testimony, the state still has an obligation to pursue the charges unless and until evidence proves that no abuse or neglect occurred, or you were not the perpetrator.
This means that you could still end up in court, even after your accuser withdraws their statement. Working with an experienced divorce lawyer or family law attorney is crucial to protecting yourself — and your loved ones — from the consequences of a guilty verdict.
Child Abuse & Neglect Defense on Long Island, NY
At Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. we understand the high stakes involved for you and your family when you face child abuse or neglect allegations on Long Island, NY. Our Long Island, NY family law firm is dedicated to advocating for parents and caregivers who have been wrongfully accused of child abuse or neglect. We’ll work hard to get you back to seeing your kids again as soon as possible.
To protect your parental rights, you need a knowledgeable and experienced defense team that understands how to carefully navigate both Family Court and criminal proceedings in Nassau County and Suffolk County. By acting quickly and working with an experienced attorney, you can build a strong case that challenges false claims and safeguards your future. We are here to help you through every step of this difficult process to achieve the best possible outcome for you and your children.
Don’t wait. The sooner you act, the stronger your defense. Contact our Long Island office for a free consultation at (631) 923 1910 or use the form below. We will protect your rights and your relationship with your children.
What happens when Child Protective Services (CPS) gets involved?
When CPS receives a report, they conduct a safety assessment, often visit your home, interview family members and children, and may place protective measures. You may also be summoned to Family Court, where CPS (the “respondent”) seeks orders to protect the child. Parental rights can be affected—sometimes temporarily.
What typically triggers a CPS investigation on Long Island, NY?
CPS investigations can be initiated based on reports of suspected child abuse or neglect by neighbors, teachers, doctors, or others. Reports may involve concerns about physical injuries, emotional harm, lack of supervision, or inadequate living conditions. Once a report is received, CPS evaluates its validity and decides whether to open an investigation.
Can I challenge a CPS investigation or a finding of neglect?
Yes—at any stage, your attorney can challenge CPS’s evidence, procedures, or findings. That includes disputing the validity of interviews, CPS’s risk assessment, or professional evaluations. You also have the right to appeal unfavorable decisions.
Can false allegations of abuse or neglect affect my custody or visitation rights?
Yes, even unproven allegations can influence custody decisions, as family courts in Nassau County and Suffolk County prioritize the child's safety above all else. However, a strong legal defense and evidence disproving the accusations can help maintain or restore your parental rights and access to your children.
What are my legal rights if accused of abuse or neglect?
You are entitled to legal counsel, and CPS must inform you of allegations. You have the right to attend hearings, present evidence, cross-examine witnesses, and challenge CPS claims. You can also propose a Family Court Service (FCS) plan as an alternative to continued court intervention.
How long does a CPS investigation usually take in Nassau or Suffolk County?
Investigations vary in length but generally last from a few weeks up to 60 days, or sometimes longer, depending on case complexity. CPS aims to resolve cases promptly to minimize disruption, but some cases may lead to extended monitoring or court interventions.
How can I resolve CPS cases without lengthy court battles?
Most cases are resolved through a negotiated FCS safety or treatment plan, completed with supervision and compliance. If you successfully fulfill the plan’s requirements, CPS may close the case without issuing a neglect or abuse finding in Family Court.
What constitutes child abuse or neglect under New York law?
In New York, child abuse includes physical, emotional, or sexual harm or risk of harm. Neglect involves failure to provide essentials—like food, shelter, medical care, supervision, or education. Both trigger serious legal consequences, and definitions are strictly enforced.
When should I hire an attorney, and how can a lawyer help?
Get legal counsel immediately—even during a CPS visit. It is advisable to contact an experienced family law attorney immediately after any accusation or investigation notice. Early legal guidance can help protect your rights, ensure proper handling of evidence, and prepare you for interactions with CPS or law enforcement. An experienced attorney can:
- Advocate for appropriate case planning and limited court oversight
- Negotiate alternative resolutions with CPS or Family Court
- Protect parental rights and seek dismissal when possible
- Represent you in appeals or contested hearings
What are the possible consequences of a neglect or abuse finding?
If the court finds cause, it may order mandates like parenting classes, drug/alcohol treatment, or supervised visitation. In severe or repeat cases, parental rights could be suspended or terminated, and criminal charges may also follow.
What types of evidence are important to collect if I want to defend against abuse allegations?
Relevant evidence can include medical records, photographs, text messages, emails, witness statements, and any documentation that supports your version of events or disproves the allegations. Keeping detailed records and preserving communication can be highly beneficial.
Can I request reunification therapy if allegations have affected my relationship with my child?
Yes, reunification therapy is often recommended in cases where abuse or neglect allegations have strained parent-child relationships. This therapy facilitates safe communication and rebuilding trust under professional supervision, which courts may view favorably when considering custody arrangements.
Being in family court especially when your children are on the line is extremely emotional and stressful but working with Robert and Christine put me at ease and made the process as pleasant as a situation like that can be. I have a now 3 year old daughter (who is the most important person in my life) and I’ve been working with them for over two years since my daughter was 7 months old, the case has been up and down and through it all Rob and Christine have never given up. My original case was due to a neglect charge. CPS is not easy to work with, but Rob and Christine were vigilant and I ended up getting my daughter back within 8 months and did not have to plead guilty to the neglect. Currently I am in family court to figure out a custody agreement. They are professional, empathetic, and patient. They have always explained everything thoroughly, informed me of all my options and advised me of what my best option would be. They always respond quickly when I contact them with questions or concerns and most importantly they fight for me in court and don’t give up even when things get rough. Before hiring Rob and Christine I met with other attorneys who did not make me feel confident or comfortable at all about my case, so I am very grateful to have found Rob and Christine and to be represented by such great attorneys. I highly recommend them for any family court matters and will definitely continue to use them in the future if needed.
Can Men Be Victims of Domestic Violence on Long Island, NY?
Can a Father Win Sole Child Custody?
Is Your Ex Turning Your Children Against You?
Can Text Messages Be Used Against Me?
How Can I Prove Domestic Violence Accusations are False?
How to Protect Your Child During a CPS Investigation
Will Criminal Charges Affect Your Divorce?
Do Children Get Visitation with Siblings?
GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION TODAY
Call 631-923-1910 or fill in the form below
Horberger Verbitsky, P.C. partners Robert E. Hornberger, Esq. and Christine M. Verbitsky, Esq.
Get your complimentary consultation and case evaluation with our experienced attorneys today.
Your attorney will describe the many options available and determine together which is the right solution for you. By the end of this conversation, we’ll all understand how we can best help you to move forward.
No Cost or Obligation
There is no cost or obligation for this initial consultation. It is simply an opportunity for us to get to know each other, answer your questions and learn if Hornberger Verbitsky, P.C. is right the right law firm for you. Give us a call at 631-923-1910 or fill in the short form below for your free consultation and case evaluation.
